About Us

Consultative Insurance Group

At Consultative Insurance Group, we make sure your goals are always built into the plan. Like our name suggests, we take a consultative approach. We are customer-driven; we listen, analyze your risk, then tailor the best available insurance solutions for your unique circumstances. Our team works hard to make everything we do easy, efficient, and effective; we are experienced risk management professionals providing the best customized value for your personal needs and budget—regardless of your age, experience, or background.

Our mission: We provide personal and commercial insurance products and services, utilizing a consultative process to ensure our clients get the maximum protection available for their insurance dollar.

If you have an insurance need, we’d love to help. Because we believe in more than making sure you are protected … we believe in the peace of mind that comes from knowing you have a friend in the business. To us, it’s not just insurance, it’s a relationship.

Personal:
Get a Quote.

Business:
Get a Free
Consultation.

Contact Us

Meet Our Team.

Agency Leadership

Ron Smith
Vice President
216.770.5203

Email »

Kindra Smith
Operations Manager
216.770.5197

Email »

Kathe DiMatteo
Personal Lines,
Account Manager,
Team Leader
216.770.5210

Email »

Kristine Bradley
Commercial Lines,
Account Manager,
Team Leader
216.770.5212

Email »

Insurance Sales Associates

Vickie Williams
Sales Agent
803.772.6978

Email »

Mary Delfs
Account Executive
216.770.5214

Email »

Michelle Wehe
Account Executive
216.770.5204

Email »

Christine Bohland, CISR Elite
Account Executive
216.770.5207

Email »

Tracy Larson
Account Executive
216.770.5217

Email »

Amy Liptak
Account Executive
216.770.5219

Email »

Paul Petrilla
Risk Advisor
216.770.5224

Email »

Customer Service Representatives

Kathy Leathers
Risk Placement Specialist
216.770.5211

Email »

Yvonne Walters
Account Manager,
Personal Lines
803.772.7097

Email »

Tammy Holton
Account Manager,
Personal Lines
216.770.5225

Email »

Michelle Sharp, CIC
Account Manager,
Personal Lines
216.770.5215

Email »

Maurica Easler
Business Support Specialist – Select
843.353.1972

Email »

Administrative Support

Christina Reed
Administrative Assistant
216.770.5216

Email »

Erin Payne
Administrative Assistant
216-770-5213

Email »